• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About Us
  • STEPS Virtual
  • FAQ
  • Links
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • 615.269.8844

STEPS Fitness

Nashville's Premier Personal Fitness Training Center

  • STEPS Virtual
  • Programs
    • STEPS Fitness Presents Events
    • DR. Irv’s Perfect Exercise Minute
    • Training Packages
    • Group Offerings
    • Corporate Wellness
    • Traveler’s Special
  • Personal Trainers
    • Dr. Irv Rubenstein
  • Testimonials
  • Fitness Blog
    • Dr Irv’s Fitness Blog
    • Exercise of the Month
  • Newsletters
    • Fit Happens
    • Real News Newsletter
  • Search

September 10, 2018 By Irv Rubenstein

Exercise – Sedentary Behavior = 0

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

As I wrote here, here , here and here, the science of sedentary behavior is the current variation of exercise science that is confounding experts.

Here, a NY Times fitness and wellness writer summarizes a recent study that demonstrates what I reported in this blog post way back when: that is, when people do go to the gym or park to exercise, they often counterbalance that positive behavior by minimizing movement elsewhere throughout the day.

This concept derived initially from observations on participants in weight loss programs. First, when people cut back on calories, based on predictions that are based on basal metabolic rates (BMR) and estimates of 3500 calories equalling a pound of fat, they tend to not lose weight at the rate or amount expected. Many factors contribute to this finding; one of the more stunning, however, was that many people move less when they have fewer calories in their diets.

Thus, they compensate/substitute inactivity for caloric reduction. Exercise - Sedentary Behavior = 01

Other studies that included an exercise component for weight loss or disease management also anticipated more dramatic results than they were seeing. This generated a ‘fear’ that, novice exercisers either ate more to compensate for the extra calories they were burning, or moved less elsewhere in their day or week to minimize the benefits of the study’s program.

Not long ago, some researchers settled on the phrase ‘substitution’ instead of ‘compensation’. Thus, when provided guidelines or even supervised exercise programs for managing heart disease, diabetes, or weight, people, even if they participate in the programs consistently, still find ways to move less throughout their normal day. This substitution of sedentariness for normal low-intensity movement may indeed counter any benefits the organized exercise were supposed to provide.

The question the average reader should be asking, however, is not whether such substitution is bad enough to make exercise – regimented movement – meaningless or useless. The question is, how do I justify for myself the time and effort I put into exercise even if I am going to substitute more calories or less movement elsewhere?

You see, a bout of exercise has its own value, provides its own set of benefits, separate and distinct from substituted behaviors. If it’s only about burning calories to lose weight, then exercise may be delusional if you’re going to sub in some extra servings of wine, cheese or cake. But that would, in my opinion, be a poor rationale for exercise.

Exercise – cardio, strength or flexibility – yields so many more benefits than just weight control or even blood pressure control.

Psychologically, it is calming, stress-reducing, sometimes enlightening, as when you’re trying to solve a problem and your brain works under the radar while the body sweats the details.

Exercise - Sedentary Behavior = 02

Physically, it moves body parts, enough to maintain some muscle and maybe bone mass, to maintain or even gain strength, or simply to retain tonus and elasticity to facilitate normal, pain-free (or at least pain-less) motion.

Cognitively, by assisting blood flow to the brain or making neural demands on it to learn new movements, it may slow age-related declines in reflexes, problem solving, memory and/or higher-order executive functions.

Organismically, it moves blood through organs, especially the heart, kidneys and gut, that help them perform their duties better. From men’s erectile function to women’s menstrual cycle pains, from bladders to rectums, being physically fit has been shown to confer benefits over and above, and below, body composition and even cardiac health.

Exercise, as the ACSM is proud to say, is medicine. And even if you sit more throughout the days you do exercise, even if you eat a little more or a little worse on the days you exercise, you are still getting many benefits that the research has clearly demonstrated.

So don’t despair substitutions; don’t beat yourself up for being less than perfect when it comes to incorporating an exercise program into your overall lifestyle. Just because the weight does not come off as expected, or the butt doesn’t look like J-Lo’s, or the doctor still wants you to continue taking a statin does not mean it’s not good for you.

In fact, think of it this way: if you weren’t doing your regimented exercises, do you really think you’d get any thinner, have any firmer a butt or see your cholesterol drop by doing what you’ve been doing, sedentarily?

I think not.

Related Posts:

  • REAL-News --September-2024
    REAL News - September 2024
  • Fit-Happens --Winter-2024
    Fit Happens - Winter 2024
  • FIT-Happens - -Winter -2025
    FIT Happens - Winter 2025
  • How-Hard-Do-You-REALLY-Have-to-Work?
    How Hard Do You REALLY Have to Work?
  • Fit-Happens--Winter-2023
    Fit Happens - Winter 2023
  • REAL-News--September-20242
    Weight Management's New Look
  • Part 1: GLP-1 Receptor Agonists: The New, Improved, and Not-Fully-Understood Weight Loss Drugs
    REAL News - November 2023
  • REAL-News--December-20232
    REAL News - September 2023

Comments

comments

Filed Under: Fitness Blog Tagged With: achieve well-being, calories, Exercise, field of health or exercise science, musculoskeletal improvements, science of sedentariness, sedentary

sidebar

Blog Sidebar

FREE Consultation!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Categories

  • Exercise of the Month
  • Fit Happens
  • Fitness Blog
  • General News
  • Newsletters
  • Real News
  • Trainers

Tags

achieve well-being aging Alzheimer's disease barefoot running body fat bone density burn off excess weight calories cardio cardiovascular childhood obesity covid diabetes diet dieting eating disorders Exercise exercise intensity field of health or exercise science fitness flexibility functional fitness health Heart Health higher risk of obesity lose weight low back pain mental health musculoskeletal improvements obesity osteoarthritis physical activity physically active protein reduce your risk of falling resistance training running Senior Training slows cognitive decline strength training Stretching training weight loss Weight loss vs Exercise gain weight management

Recent News

May 01

REAL News – May 2025

Apr 01

REAL News – April 2025

Mar 18

Fit Happens – Spring 2025

Mar 01

REAL News – March 2025

Feb 01

REAL News – February 2025

Reviews

Search Our Directory

Footer Widget Header

Affiliations

  • american-college-of-sports-medicine
  • american-council-on-exercise
  • biometrics
  • exercise-etc-inc
  • national-strength-and-conditioning-association
  • renewed-support

STEPS Fitness | 2424 21st Ave. S. Suite #100 | Nashville, TN 37212 | 615.269.8844 p

© 2025 Nashville's Premier Personal Fitness Training Center | Designed by Ponder Consulting ®

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok